Recruitment agencies are useless
11-March-2010
*
* Your Gripe Gripe List Quick Gripe Comments Gripe Poll Resources Contact Us Advertise Home *
* prev
next *
 

Recruitment agencies are useless

Leave a comment Leave a comment 
Related Gripes Related Gripes 
Random Gripe Random Gripe 
Feedburner Gripes by email 
 
 
I am looking to relocate in the next few months, I'm not sure where to, but just fancy a change of pace from Bristol; I kind of miss Cardiff so I am going to start there.  I have tried changing jobs, changing house, changing state of mind, however, I think it's time to move on and taste the air of somewhere new then maybe, just maybe, I can start to relax when I turn 30 in June.

I am looking for jobs in the local areas.  As I work in recruitment myself, I'm not at all surprised when I discover that it's difficult to find a job without going through a recruitment agency.  New locations are tricky to work out; who does what, where, when and how etc.  You would think that a recruitment agency would be able to help wouldn't you? 

Leave comment below and tell us about your experiences

Here's the problem.  I am looking for a change of pace with a new job in another sector or change of career doing something completely different, however I seem to be pigeon-holed into this one category of work.  It's not the employers that are doing that.  A well trained HR officer or manager should be able to peel away the layers of a CV and work out if you will be good for business.  Yet the dumb recruitment agencies I've worked with so far can't see past the box they've neatly dumped me into!  They tell me that they're not putting me forward for other jobs to protect the client.  Hello? I'm sure they can make their own minds up and tell the difference between a dodgy CV, and someone who just wants to expand their horizons!  All that I am asking is for an opportunity to get my CV and a covering letter in front of a potential employer.  Maybe that could then lead to sitting down and having a conversation with them if they like what they see.  Is that too much to ask?

Recruitment agencies, an unnecessary evil

As far as I can see, it's the recruitment agencies that are putting up all the road blocks to self development.  They are making it impossible for candidates to make contact with the right people in a company because they interfere too much.  Everything out there is seems to be bogged down with 'new business preferred suppliers' and Christ knows what else for that matter.  Recruitment agencies are an unnecessary evil and I'm hoping that this credit crunch will shut some of them down.  With their KPIs and targets, no wonder the recruitment market is like this.

If you're in this line of business already, I bet your thinking 'Why can't you find your own job then if recruitment agencies are such a stumbling block?'  The reason I can't is because of the commitment and the long hours I put in to do a professional job in my chosen sector.  It's hard to find enough time to do all the searching that would be required.

My gripe is really about those unprofessional agencies that are stuck in this world of KPI's, CV's to interviews, and interviews to placements.  They way I do things, I'm more interested in getting the right candidate to the right job.  I make as much, probably more than the 'KPI monkeys' and my candidates respect me when I say 'No, they don't fit'.  I also don't make false promises that I can't keep.

Honesty is missing in recruitment and the dishonest car salesman type recruiters are everywhere!

By: Derek


Other Related Gripes

Temporary recruitment agencies unhelpful
Getting a job after redundancy
Minimum wage for young people is pathetic
Looking for a job and getting no response
British jobs for British workers
I really hate job application forms
Coming into work with a hangover
In business, the so-called 'glass ceiling' doesn't exist
Pathologist's Assistant - It's just a job
People who toot their own horn
Interview for job that's already gone
Recruitment agencies - the truth
My boss is a bully
Lazy people don't use their swipe cards
Young workers are exploited
Employers want too much
Sales and marketing jargon
Issues faced by homeworkers
Employers stingy with holiday





Visitor Comments

Please read this before you post

Enter your comments in the space below

Name or nickname


Remember my name



 
Am persuing Msc(IT)..looking for a parttime job...
*IBBU  07-Feb-2010 16:06

 
You're certainly right there....... if a company wants an ideal candidate they should forget about these CV agency shops that cannot see through the details of a CV and interview candidates directly. Agency's will only send someone who is currently doing the same job, not someone who has similar experiences & could do the job just as well, if not better.
Personally, I've been sent to many interviews where the position is nothing like what my experiences suit, but at least I'm enabling a dumb recruitment consultant (often a young salesperson with no knowledge of the business world) to reach their targets & keep their job for another day.
Recruitment agencies know nothing about recruitment.... just sales!.
*WHIFFY  07-Feb-2010 13:49

 
Something should be done about agencies advertising fake jobs simply to aquire your details! Just today I had another experience of this where I've applied for a position suitable to my skills and the Agency have asked me to provide additional information. Ofcourse this gets your hopes up and you eagerly await a reply. The reply I got however was NOT related to the position I applied for and was for a role I CLEARLY wasnt qualified to do. Quite simply they got my details, then gave me a nice big "See Ya" by sending a position they KNEW I couldnt apply for. Whats more annoying is knwoing that some teenager on a minimum wage with the OTE carrot dangled infront of them, has duped me into believing a company was interested in me when it wasnt, simply so they can increase their database. In some cases, they are playing with peoples lives.
*Splashdown  11-Dec-2009 17:02

 
Agency staff get a bonus pat on the back for keeping an up to date list of names, addresses, phone/email, college certificates, tickets,experience,etc on as many people as possible, the owners like a large volume of names so that they can make use of them in their day to day...
the standard amount for keeping up at present seems to be an extra £50 in the pay packet each week, hence a lot of fake non existant job adverts, you spend lots of money getting your cv printed and comb bound by the box load, send them out, they extract the info they want from your printed cv or email then bin it and keep the nice shiny £11.99 folder you sent it in the post inside...
*seeitcoming  10-Nov-2009 00:41

 
You know, I think some of the jobs that get posted up on www.jobserve.com and www.jobsite.com are in fact fake. Why do I believe this? For one thing you apply for loads of jobs and hear very little back if anything at all (no, my CV isn't that bad!). Secondly, you've applied for a job and go look for it on the recruitment agency's website and lo-and-behold - it isn't even there. I think we're actually chasing ghosts here and these companies are promoting jobs that don't exist to make themselves look bigger than they really are, perhaps to gather CV's ahead of their competitors.

We're finding things hard enough right now without these silly games!
*Fed up jobseeker  02-Oct-2009 10:53

 
I don't agree with John's comment of the agency will contact you if something comes in. The amount of times that I have called them to be told they have nothing and when I check the website there is at least one job that I could have been put forward for and when I enquire about it I get told it's been filled already!! When I actually picked them up on this I was met with silence.
*magenta  17-Sep-2009 16:58

 
Recruitment agencies always say that they have your best interests but they are looking out for themselves the whole time.
i too get that they cannot put you forward for certain jobs because you haven't actually had that job title but the job description is every thing that you have done in previous jobs. They then stick you in a job to get their commission that they know that you are going to be utterly bored in just because you did it years ago.
I
*Magenta  17-Sep-2009 16:53

 
Cher said "it's frustrating to feel that my work life and subsequent happiness depends on these agencies"

I say " get off your ass and go get a job yourself ! "

Agencies are for idiots, I refuse to take applications from agencies as the type of person I am looking for would know how to apply for the position themselves.
*Employer  10-Sep-2009 16:25

 
Derek,

I'm completely with you in your gripe. it's frustrating to feel that my work life and subsequent happiness depends on these agencies who don't care really what you want and are only trying to tick their boxes. Its a no win situation either being registered with them or not. Whenever I have entered a company as a temp after a couple of days of proving myself I have been asked to stay and they have found other jobs for me to do to keep me there as long as possible which just shows that I am a good worker. Right now I'm stuck with whatever the agency deem suitable for me and can't do a thing about it - it seems. If I moan at them they will stop calling me, if I don't moan at them, they don't call me anyway. It's just not right that they should have so much control. It's not right, it's not fair, and I can't see a way out of the trap.
*Cher  21-Aug-2009 15:56

 
Deb,

If the agency has something for you they will contact you. The more time they spend telling you they dont have anything for you.....the less time they have to actually find you a position.
*John  22-Jul-2009 21:05

 
You are probably not qualified for the type of work you "want" to perform. I would not submit you to my clients either. Would I hire a car mechanic to build my house, simply because he wants to "expand his horrizons"!
*John  22-Jul-2009 21:01

 
I contact the Agencies every week or fortnight just to keep my name near the top of the pile. Today the well-know High Street Agent asked "Hello Deb, how can I help you?"

to which I felt like replying "Darling, if you don't know by now, best you change your job..."
*Deb  21-Jul-2009 17:55


View more comments on this gripe


 
*   *
* © 2000-2009 The Weekly Gripe. All rights reserved. Please see our privacy policy and disclaimer.   Site Map *