Comic Relief, is it just a rip off?
18-March-2010
*
* Your Gripe Gripe List Quick Gripe Comments Gripe Poll Resources Contact Us Advertise Home *
* prev
next *
 

Comic Relief, is it just a rip off?

Leave a comment Leave a comment 
Related Gripes Related Gripes 
Random Gripe Random Gripe 
Feedburner Gripes by email 
 
 

First of all, let me say that I’m not a “bah humbug” kind of guy and would like to think that I am just as charitable (if not more so) than the next guy.  I always buy into all the Comic Relief and Children in need stuff as it’s just been the normal thing to do ever since I was a child.  I would guess that the same is true for a lot of people out there.

But when I look around and even do some research on the Internet, I still see lots of the kind of things we have been paying to put a stop to for about the last 20 years now.  And not only that, I have never seen one thing to suggest that the money is really being spent in the way we are told.

A clown face, red nose day, Comic Relief

So where are all these kids that we have allegedly helped?  In Africa?  Although it is conveniently very far away I don't think for one minute that tiny bore hole in the ground costs 10 million a year to maintain!  I see all this money being collected but have no idea where it is actually being spent, because it certainly isn’t anywhere near me.  If I could just see a bit more evidence of the good being done then perhaps I would not be so suspicious.

Comic Relief... So where is the other 30p going to?

Now there’s another thing that makes me feel a bit uneasy about this situation.  The television and radio companies (BBC radio is the worst) charge you £1 if you send a text to them, with 70p of this money going to Comic Relief.  Err… excuse me, so where is the other 30p going to?

I'm pretty good at arithmetic (taps away on the calculator) and I reckon that 30% of all the money from these texts must add up quite a pretty penny.  Why should we be asked to give generously when there are companies out there using these events to make a hefty profit? Surely they can do it at a reduced rate for Comic Relief?  Why can't a larger portion or even better all of the money go to the people who REALLY need it?  Oh no, of course not because it’s not the big companies that stick their hands in their pockets; that’s a job for us - the “paying” public.

I really do think that by simply doing the easy thing and giving to Comic Relief just to ease your conscience is actually taking money away from the real charities that could use our help.  Does anyone else agree?

By: Jimmy Wyld


Other Related Gripes

Why does food aid take so long to distribute?
Charity shops are getting greedy
Parents complain about disabled CBeebies presenter
TV complaints, if you don't like it turn it off
Are we really being ripped off?
So many problems still to solve
Christmas is just a spend fest
People are nothing but sheep
No more Chris Evans radio show
Celebrities that endorse charities
Cash for honours scandal
Adverts on television and radio
Issues with the media
Charity skydive but who pays?
Reality TV shows aren't real life
Charity muggers are irritating





Visitor Comments

Please read this before you post

Enter your comments in the space below

Name or nickname


Remember my name



 
Only mugs give to charity.
Remember people
CHARITY BEGINS AT HOME.
Dont give them a second thought!
*Matrix  19-Dec-2009 21:48

 
The only relief my wheelchair bound daughter has had, is being relieved of her inheritance by the csa, to be given to an idle slag.

So bad is this that it is almost comical.

The csa, taking money of disabled kids since 1993.
*Gainsborough lad.  28-Nov-2009 23:58

 
Remember you can access any charity's annual accounts which should give a rough salary breakdown and how large their reserves are - the NSPCC makes interesting reading.
*Darken  25-Nov-2009 17:02

 
Has anyone looked at the comic relief's jobs being advertised and seen what salary is being paid. money kept in a bank account and interest which people have donated is paid to these jobs. I wonder what comic relief's Head of Media and Public affairs is paid and the rest of them? wait for this one £250 to spend on any hobby. .i'll give to local charities. not going to do any more absailing down buildings for this charity . H of M & P A you know who you are!!
*Artic K  19-Aug-2009 21:38

 
I am old enough to remember the first "Live Aid" in 1985 fronted by the then Boomtown Rats' Bob Geldorf. I particularly remember him becoming animated and swearing on TV - something that wasn't done then!

20 years later, there was a repeat.

Why?

In 1985 I wanted to help the world. I gave what money I could in the belief that my donation would help. Clearly it didn't.

Today, I choose my donations to charities very carefully.

I keep my donations to small, local charities who don't have vast reserves in their bank account.

I still care about people who struggle in the third world, which isn't Africa alone.

But if you listen to the podcast of a Mr. Jack Clark, who is far more knowledgeable than me, you'll see why.

Just do a google search for: "Blast the right" and scroll down the page to podcast number 137 - and listen to it, and you'll see why music concerts and charity giving aren't the answer.
*CharityGiver  10-Aug-2009 23:49

 
Doesn't Terry Wogan still get a huge salary for presenting Children in Need????
*it's all wrong!  05-Aug-2009 09:26

 
Comic relief is Absolutely not a rip-off.It is a pure example of christianity in action.Anyone who thinks there is some kind of "conspiracy" behind it is very sadly crippled with emotional cynisism.
*Mr Hicks  08-Jul-2009 09:45

 
How do people manage to give all this money to Comic Relief when there is a credit crunch on? Will any of the money be going to families of those who's fathers and mothers have been made reduntant in the UK and have nothing left? Nope. I'm not against charity (I'm running the race for life), but I don't get how there is so much money in the purses of our nation for Africa and so on, when we ourselves are supposed to be in an economic slump. Are people stupid or what? They should be saving at a time like this, not giving money away - sorry but sometimes charity does and shoud begin at home.
*Me me me  18-Mar-2009 20:45

 
I agree with you Jimmy Wyld !
Approaching £60 million raised for 'charity' is admirable.....but just for the heck of accountancy, HOW MUCH of license fee money was actually spent in producing the six hours of celeb 'entertainment' ? The kind-hearted British public donate twice........firstly by funding the various 'performances' , then by donating directly ! Does the BBC ever reveal the actual costs involved ? Is this a transparent annual event ?
*Verity  14-Mar-2009 21:38

 
I cant believe the public can be so naive and so galable about this comic relief its sad
*jo  13-Mar-2009 21:50

 
There's no such thing as charity anymore, it's all just business - getting money out of your pocket into theirs and making you feel good about doing it until they want another installment from you.

Ask yourself: what car do the directors of such and such charity drive? what kind of house do they have? how much do they pay for their websites, TV and magazine ads?

And why (as the original poster here said) have none of the problems these charities are supposed to be dealing with have been solved by now after all the millions poured into them?

The answer: if they were solved, these guys would be out of their jobs, BMW's and million pound houses.
*Cynical and proud  13-Mar-2009 21:29

 
it is very good that we are devoloping in this comic relif we are helping the poor people.
*ehsan  11-Mar-2009 17:48


View more comments on this gripe


 
*   *
* © 2000-2009 The Weekly Gripe. All rights reserved. Please see our privacy policy and disclaimer.   Site Map *