The Weekly Gripe
06-September-2010
*
* Your Gripe Gripe List Quick Gripe Comments Gripe Poll Resources Contact Us Advertise Home *
* prev
next *
 

Guy meets girl and here's what happens

Your Ad Here Random Gripe Random Gripe 
Related Gripes Related Gripes 
Feedburner Subscribe to feed 
 
 
  Here's my situation.  Guy meets girl and they fall in love.  Guy has a child from previous relationship gone wrong.  Girl takes on child as her own and every fortnight willingly acts as second mother to the child.  Guy and girl get engaged and set wedding date then a couple of weeks before wedding, news is broken that another women is alleging that guy is father to different baby.  Guy and girl decide to ignore this as he is insistent it can't be his and in the event it is pursued they will deal with it then.

Guy and girl get married and live in general happily ever after for almost a year with child on alternative weekends, happy that is until a letter arrives from the CSA to say he needs to pay maintenance for the other child.  Guy still disputes paternity.  Girl feels like she's been punched in the guts and her world has been up-ended.  Guy gets calls the CSA immediately and disputes paternity so DNA test will ensue - pending.

The gripe is that Girl feels like she has willingly accepted Guys child into her life but shouldn't have to do the same with another if it turns out it did biologically come from Guy.  Girl debates her (premature) feelings considering the outcome could go one way or another.  Girl feels like if it is Guys child then they will of course have to pay maintenance but that she doesn't want it in their lives.  But can she live with issuing an ultimatum of her or child to Guy; and on the opposite scale how will she manage to not resent Guy or their lives together if she bites her tongue and 'goes with the flow' when she knows that's not what she wants?

Side Note - Guy says he was only with the woman for a couple of weeks.  She also has 4 other children to 4 different fathers - not that that matters much in the grand scheme of things.  Girl thinks that if she wanted to take on other people's children then she would have adopted them - she was happily prepared to take on first child but not prepared to accept any others.

People bang on about rights of this potential new child, and Guys rights to see the child...  but what about Girls rights?  Does she have any at all in a situation like this or should she put up and shut up and resent the rest of her married life (how long it may last) feeling like that?  At the very least does she not have the right to express her feelings to Guy; and how on earth can they work through this positively when it all seems like it could potentially be doom and gloom?

Submitted By: doomandgloom



Please also check out the main gripes section with reader comments.

Related Quick Gripes

Why do I have to do everyone’s job for them?
Fed up with fireworks late at night
Working tax credits a complete sham
Too much sexism on GMTV
Absent father dodges responsibilities
How can anyone afford to be a student at uni?
Ex turns daughter against me after CSA claim
'Poor' consumers bombarded by seasonal advertising
CSA maintenance payments too high
CSA money makes a woman greedy
What kind of man would walk out on his kids?
CSA mistakes with payments and arrears calculation
Ex wife taking the kids away from him
Ex husband won't pay child support
Step daughter worth less according to the CSA?

 
*   *
* © 2000-2009 The Weekly Gripe. All rights reserved. Please see our privacy policy and disclaimer.   Site Map *