Plastic carrier bags, recycling and environment
I am fed up to the back teeth with the 'nanny' politics surrounding supermarket plastic carrier bags. For months now I've researched the science, claims and counter-claims, and the bottom line is that, whilst we should all seek to conserve this world we live on and reduce our consumption of resources, the focus on an absolute ban of (so-called) single use plastic carrier bags is a totally disproportionate distraction from the the environmental matters that people should be getting steamed up about.
loading their jute bags into a brand new Toyota...
The reality of life is that while I take re-usable bags with me if I know I'm going shopping, many's the time I shop on the spur. On one such occasion recently, I walked out of Asda leaving over £100 of printer cartridges at the till because they wouldn't give me a bag.
At the same store a few months previously I stood behind a couple at the till and was served up a pious and overly loud diatribe about how damaging 'single use' bags are and how people who use them are irresponsible. As I walked out the store with my 'single use' bag to get the bus home I espied my couple loading their jute bags into a brand new Toyota Landcruiser.
Please can the anti-bag 'police' just pipe down a bit and let some balance and proportion come back into the debate? Let's focus on industrial pollution. Let's focus on air travel pollution. Let's focus on vehicle pollution. Let's focus on the 99.6% of landfill waste that ISN'T plastic bags.
By: Cauliflower
Comments from visitors
cauliflower is a LOSER - 16-Nov-10 16:42
If I do a spur of the moment shop, I expect a free carrier. The Spar are terrible at this though. They don't provide single use carriers, only 10p re-usables.
I got fed up with the pile of re-usabled bags I had collected at Spar so stopped shopping there for small items. to me, that shop is no longer usable because of this silly 10p bag thing - which let's be honest, is a money spinner for the Spar.
If these shops were so very concerned with the environment, their products wouldn't come from half way around the world with all the pollution involved in their carriage.
We can make nuclear fusion, surely some clever scientist can invent a cheap, biodegradeable single use carrier bag?
keep the change ya filthy anim - 14-Feb-10 23:01
Carrier bags- make about 20 for a penny, sell them for 5, 10 or even 20p each, ha ha easy profit, more markup than the stuff in the basket...an ever super duper lasting jute or cotton bag, sir....made in india or china for 4p and that will be a pound each, the slightly thicker bags with plastic handles are £2.20 each.....still wont stop illegal dumping of rubbish in the sea by large companies in various countries or "waste management " companies managing to ship rubbish abroad to dissapear.....just like the certain £2000 allowance which is eaten up in mark ups, both are beneficial to corporate tycoons...
All that will happen is this, they know that you need carrier bags unless you reverse the car up to the shop door, which you are no longer legally allowed to do, if you bring a bag back, the checkout person will beep in the price of the bag anyway because they have been warned to or else by "head office" so you get peed off and think if I'm going to pay every time for a bag I might as well get a new one each time" and you will end up hoarding expensive carrier bags until, guess what , you get fed up and out of space and throw them away anyway, then they will probably charge you for recycling by that point...
A conservative guess at the "average" age of items dumped there, would be well less than ten years old,
And yet carrier bags seem to be the root of all evil, even Gormless Brown had to give them a mention in one of his budgets.
Gainsborough lad. - 17-Jan-10 20:09
Incineration Generation - 15-Nov-09 23:49
I have a fridge freezer that is 20 years old, I forget how long I have had the microwave but it is the only one I have ever had and my armchairs came to me third hand. I buy new stuff only when the old runs out.
I don’t own a tumble dryer and air dry washing outside and have not flown anywhere for 11 years. I walk everywhere or get the bus and have been taking my own bags for the weekly supermarket shop for 40 years.
Apparently I am a threat to the environment though because, having for once forgotten to bring my own, I asked for a carrier bag in the supermarket and got a lecture from the snotty kid serving me.
When the world ends I will, apparently, be to blame so can I apologize in advance for the inconvenience?
Gainsborough lad. - 11-Nov-09 23:46
grumpyoldwoman
GRUMPYOLDWOMAN - 10-Nov-09 14:10
That purchase will last forever, no re-cycling for this, my ten year old lad has been promised it when I snuff it, and knows what is in every drawer.
Gainsborough lad. - 10-Nov-09 12:09
Something else that annoys me with bits & pieces for the kitchen is that colours go in & out of "fashion" so quickly. When my current kitchen was new I went for utensils, teapot, oven gloves etc in dark green & brown, to go with a dark brown hob & pale green walls. These things gradually needed replacing & then I found the colours I had were "out"; after a bit of searching I got the impression that it would be easier to re-decorate the kitchen to one of the colours that was currently "in" than keep trying to get the colours I wanted!
The same goes for bathroom stuff, I think you would need to keep buying a new suite every 5 years to keep up with the fahion in towel colours.
Come to think of it, maybe that's why people buy a new sofa every 2 or 3 years; they need new cushions and have to buy a new sofa to go with the current "in" colour for cushions because they can't get any that match the old sofa!
grumpyoldwoman
GRUMPYOLDWOMAN - 10-Nov-09 08:18
New settee every two years? are they fastening the springs under the seat with staples on purpose?, so they come undone and you have to buy a new one, more landfill,
All drink tastes better from glass bottles, why do we put up with tins? (of every different size).
I am gobsmacked that the EU haven't dictated to us that we do the same as them,
Gainsborough lad. - 10-Nov-09 00:23
My grandpa bought my mum and my grandma a microwave each back in 1984, it was a Toshiba. Gran had a white one, mum received a dark brown one. They were huge and operated with 2 dials. My mums packed up as we moved house back in 1998 so did well. My grandma still has hers and its still going strong which is amazing considering my mum has gone through 3 microwaves since 1998.
I remember it wasn't so long ago, again around the year 2000 that my gran's Hoover twin-tub washing device finally gave up its 1970s/1980s technology.
It seems that things aren't made to last these days.
Youthful Griper - 9-Nov-09 16:55
I hate the fact that consumer appliances seem to be looked on as disposable these days. I have a microwave of similar vintage to yours, a Samsung, bought in 1987. It's the only one I've ever had but nowadays it seems you're lucky if they last 5 years. Then you have the bother of getting a new one and disposing of the old one. Still, so many people seem to make a hobby of shopping these days; it gives them an excuse!
Then, as you say, there are the people who have to have a new sofa every couple of years or their life just isn't complete. I suppose they are the ones who go down to DFS on Boxing Day. Personally you'd have to pay me; I've far better things to do at Christmas!
As to the thing with the carrier bags, I do it all the time! There isn't one supermarket that sells everything I need and as I have Tesco, Sainsbury, Asda and Morrisons all within easy reach I go to whichever I need to at the time, and trot out a variety of (long lasting or falling apart) bags from all of them!
Deposit bottles should be brought back by law. You can say what you like about the Germans; they do know how to do things effficiently!
Kit; that sounds like an excellent idea from Holland; it could be organised quite easily I think, although I can't see the binmen clearing up the leftovers. Some women already do a similar thing with clothes I think.
As to plastic bags; I keep re-using them till they fall apart. It's not just a problem with landfill, large numbers find their way into the sea where they are eaten by turtles and other animals, as when they are floating full of water they look like jellyfish. The end result is usually fatal. I use as few as possible; I even re-use fruit & veg bags if they are clean. The staff in Tesco quite often have to weigh apples in a Morrisons bag! As I use them up I'm gradually getting a collection of cloth bags.
grumpyoldwoman
GRUMPYOLDWOMAN - 9-Nov-09 10:51
Kit
It keeps a lot of useful items out of landfill, saves the raw materials and energy that would have been needed to produce new goods and saves people money. People treat it as a sort of day out, like going to multiple car boot sales, except no money is involved.





