Garage had my car for five months
12-May-2008
*
* Your Gripe Gripe List Quick Gripe Comments Gripe Poll About Us Site Map Resources Home *
*   *
 

Garage had my car for five months

Bookmarking, Google, Yahoo, MSN, Digg, Delicious, Redit, Furl and many more Add To Any >> 
Feedburner Subscribe to feed >> 
Other Related Gripes >> 
Email To A Friend >> 

 
 

My recently purchased Renault Laguna diesel estate was such a responsive car and a delight to drive until one afternoon it spluttered to a halt.  The green flag man told me that it looked like a fuel problem and suggested that he transport my car the forty or so miles back home on the back of his lorry.

Later that week I placed my lifeless Laguna in the safe hands of my local electro diesel specialist garage.  “I will have it sorted out in a couple of days mate” said the mechanic.  Great I thought, a couple of days off work would suite me fine.

So I waited a couple of days and then walked over to the garage and I was advised that the problem was actually the heater plugs.  No problem I thought, I won’t need to re-mortgage the house to pay the bill.

A renault laguna

I telephoned the next day to see if I could have my car back and it was around about then that I entered the twilight world of rip-off garages.  The mechanic had APPARENTLY found further faults in the following order.  The flywheel sensor needed replacing, the MAS air intake sensor needed replacing, the ECU needed repairing, the fuel pump was damaged beyond repair and it will have to be replaced with a new one.

Five weeks later I got a bit miffed with the garage and so I said that I wanted the car back in seven days either working properly or in the same condition that it was when I gave it to them.  They told me to collect the invoice and my car on the following Tuesday and that they would telephone me when the car was ready.  I did not receive a telephone call and so I went to the garage on the Wednesday, just so that it would absolutely be ready for me to pick up.

When I was shown the invoice for the work carried out I could not believe my eyes.  The bill was £1,300.00 and the invoice stated that they could not fix the ECU properly so they were only charging me £309.00 for that!  The mechanic said that would not be charging me for removing the security immobilizer from the car! After contemplating telling the mechanic where to stick his bill I though I better check the car first.

When I checked the car I noticed that the fuel pump was a second hand one and that when I started the car the dashboard lit up like a Christmas tree with flashing lights.  The mechanic said that he could stop the lights flashing by removing the bulbs!  When I told the mechanic that I thought the car was not ready to go back on the road, he said that it was my fault because I did not collect it the day before!

I decided to teach the garage a lesson in life and sued their butts off.  When they received the County Court letter they advised me that if I don’t withdraw my claim they would tell the judge that they found illegal fuel in my fuel tank!  I called the H.M Customs and excise to investigate their claim.  Within an hour they (customs) called me back to inform that despite a thorough investigation they could not find any illegal fuel in my car!

The garage has since offered to tear up their invoice so long as I don’t talk about what they have put me through and to withdraw my legal action.  Every meeting that I have had with them has been recorded on my MP3 player including the time he suggested that the best cure for my cars problems would be “a match a gallon of petrol and blow it up”.

To date they have had my car for FIVE MONTHS.

I was thinking of selling tickets for the court case that will be on the 13 March, but I think I will have more fun writing an account of what happened in court when the day comes.

By: Royboywales


Other Related Gripes

Car stuck in the garage for four months
Incompetent garage couldn't fix my car
Garage bill was way too high
Ford Focus starting problems
Renault Laguna with endless problems
Garage ignored my wishes
Van insurance company lied
Nice cars go to the wrong people
Fed up with my unreliable VW Golf
Vehicle repairs at rip off garage
Rip off MOT and servicing
Burger vans are a rip off
Free safety check costs a grand
Car mechanics and used car dealerships
Car service at your own risk
Car damage caused by potholes
Car insurance company useless
Rover in administration who cares?




Sponsored Links


Visitor Comments

Please read this before you post

Enter your comments in the space below

Name or nickname


Remember my name



 
Ive the same problem.
the garage has had my car since 6th March 2008 and still has It to date 16th April 2008, I asked for a reconditioned engine,they claim the Ignition timing is at fault and caused the big ends and pistons to go thus bumping up the price.
I know that ignition timing does not do this and they are trying to buff me off, I suspect it was a problem with the oil pump which will be supplied with the reconditioned engine. I havent paid for the repairs but just wondering if I should under protest, It will be a fight to get the money back.
*kevin  16-Apr-2008 14:48

 
This is a disgrace, and typical of many garages around. it's about time mechanics were monitored more closely and answerable to 'a higher body' therfore enabling customers to resolve unlawful behavior, much quicker. We are have just received our car back after 6 months in the garage but are still arguing over the bill! It also cost us £2500 in hiring and insuring cars during the 6 months. All because the mechanic couldn't fit the timing belt properly!
*terry  25-Mar-2008 13:57

 
Im allso having trouble my bill so far is -£1,000 . my repaires arent yet complete ,I now hear it has to go to another garage for electrical checks , Im feeling pretty fed up I estimate in the end it will cost me close to £2,000 . I only had the car for one day .
*mark  27-Feb-2008 20:30

 
This sounds vary familar to what I am going through now... But difference with my case is that its with a multi-nation household car dealer... Do have any suggestion on how to push this issue to take this case to court...
*MICK  06-Dec-2007 12:16

 
Yes its a good idea to name and shame garages, however bear in mind that in doing so the website can get into all sorts of trouble from small "cyber bullying" small garages. Threats of legal action for defamatory and libelous material etc. etc. You get the picture! Would be nice to champion the consumer but sometimes its not worth it. Big companies like BT and Sky don't give a damn, but the small companies go for the jugular - I guess a bad press means they have more to loose.
*I agree.. but...  27-Nov-2007 00:27

 
Perhaps having the garages name will help many others, I think.
*MARCO  04-Nov-2007 20:12

 
Hi , any news on the judgement? It would be nice to hear how you resolved your problem!
*Fast Forward  21-May-2007 16:49

 
What is the garage's name, where is it? Is it a good idea to have a list of garages from hell?
*Andy  05-Apr-2007 12:43

 
I expect your car is being stripped of all its pricey accessories whilst it is there. You won't notice this of course, but anything worth stripping is probably being taken out and replaced with an inferior fitting looking much the same as the "real thing".

Take them to a small claims court and charge them £4,999 for loss of use of the car.

Ask for the car to be moved immediately to a Renault garage, who should fix it under warranty
*Take the extreme view  28-Feb-2007 18:44

 
Unfortunately you seem to have fallen for a common trik of less than honest garages, if you take your car into a garage with a specific fault which is then diagnosed, there is a good chance a mechanic may find a number of other components that are faulty but not directly contributing to your original specific fault.

Garage then says the all the following items are faulty and need replacing (which they may genuinely need replacing) but omits to mention only a few, possibly even one is the cause of your specific fault.

If you are presented with a huge list of faulty items it may be worth having a second opinion.
RE the £309 for attempting to fix the ECU, it may be irritating in the extreme that he hasent fixed the fault but still wants money, but looking at this objectively the mechanic is a professional with an hourly rate and may have taken £309 of time to look into this. Sure, it may call into question the guys competence but his hourly rate must be met.
*7 of 9  28-Feb-2007 17:22


View more comments on this gripe


 
*   *
* © 2000-2008 The Weekly Gripe. All rights reserved. Please see our privacy policy and disclaimer. *